Dating During Divorce or Separation

Dating during divorce can have legal consequences both for the divorcing spouse and their new partner. Dating while separated can hold up and complicate the divorce proceedings, can effect custody and visitation decisions, and rarely but possibly, depending on the state, may be grounds for a lawsuit.

Effects on the Divorce

Dating while going through a divorce can have a number of negative effects on the divorce proceedings, both in court and emotionally. Additionally, while every state is now a no-fault divorce state, marital misconduct can still be considered in some situations. Marital misconduct can encompass a wide variety of actions, including adultery and cruelty. During the proceedings, the fact that a dating spouse is already separated will be noted, but that does not necessarily mean the circumstances of the new relationship will not be considered. For example, the judge might disapprove of the dating spouse’s behavior and develop a bias against them. While such a bias is ostensibly unacceptable in the U.S. legal system, judges are human and biases are natural and even probable in some instances.

In addition, in some states the new relationship may be considered in the division of property or alimony determinations, so the dating spouse may not get as much as they want out of the divorce depending on the new partner’s financial circumstances. This is especially true if the dating spouse begins cohabitating with their new partner during the divorce process. Some states have laws stating that a spouse cohabitating with a parter of the opposite sex is presumed to have a decreased need for spousal support.

Dating before a divorce is final is one of the typical issues that causes heightened conflict during a divorce. The other spouse, if they are not dating, may develop the idea that the dating spouse was committing adultery even if that idea hadn’t surfaced before. Or, the other spouse may simply suffer anger and hurt as a result of the limited amount of time it apparently took the dating spouse to recover and move on. Either way, the other spouse may become confrontational, may become unwilling to compromise and obstinate during the proceedings, or, at best, may become cold and distrustful of the dating spouse. These feelings can cause property division to be more difficult, as well as other aspects of the divorce.

Dating and Child Custody

Dating while in the process of a divorce may also affect child custody determinations. Seeing parents date new partners is difficult for children, especially older children, and the new relationship may cause older children discomfort such that they decide residence with the other spouse would be more desirable. Although many courts don’t take children’s wishes into consideration, some will, especially under the circumstance where a child is uncomfortable with a parent’s new partner.

When one spouse is dating, the other spouse is likely to be resistant to shared custody agreements as well. A divorce and the prospect of a new partner replacing them is often too much for a spouse to cope with, and may cause disagreements and unwillingness to come to a compromise with regard to custody arrangements. When left up to the court, the judge will make a determination as to which parent should have primary physical and legal custody based on the best interests of the children, and if there is a real or perceived discomfort with the new parter experienced by the children, it is very likely to effect the amount of time each parent and particularly the dating parent is awarded.

If the new partner makes the children feel uncomfortable, whether it has to do with the partner personally or it’s related to the children feeling that the partner may be at fault or contributing to the separation and divorce, this is likely to have an effect on custody decisions made by the judge. As such, a spouse who decides to date during the separation is wise to keep the children and the new partner separate to avoid arousing these types of issues during the proceedings.

The Risk of Alienation of Affection or Criminal Conversation Lawsuits

In addition to the possible financial or custody consequences of dating while separated, you may be subject to archaic criminal statutes that make adultery a misdemeanor. This depends on your state – most states no longer consider adultery a crime, but some do.

Further, your new partner may be subject to legal action as well, especially if your relationship began before separation. In some states, the spurned spouse can sue for “alienation of affection.” An alienation of affection suit is when a spouse who was cheated on sues a third party essentially for stealing the other spouse and breaking up the marriage. The cheating spouse and the third party do not necessarily even have to have a sexual relationship – in some places, a family member who convinces one spouse to leave the other might be liable for alienation of affection (though this is very uncommon).

Another, even less common, suit is one for “criminal conversation.” In a criminal conversation suit, the wronged spouse again sues, but for the suit to proceed there must have been a sexual relationship. Also, the relationship must have begun prior to the married couple’s separation.

Though alienation of affection and criminal conversation suits are not very common, they do exist. That’s why it’s so important to speak to your lawyer if you plan to or have already begun a relationship during your separation. Dating during separation may not be a big deal, depending on where you live, but it is best if you wait until your divorce is finalized.

Case Studies: Dating During Divorce or Separation

Case Study 1: The Impact on Divorce Proceedings

In this case study, a divorcing spouse decides to start dating before the divorce is finalized. The article discusses how dating while separated can complicate the divorce proceedings and potentially affect custody and visitation decisions.

It highlights the potential bias of judges and the consideration of marital misconduct, such as adultery, in certain situations.

Case Study 2: Financial Consequences of Dating During Divorce

This case study explores how dating during divorce can affect the division of property and alimony determinations. It mentions that in some states, a spouse cohabitating with a new partner of the opposite sex may have a decreased need for spousal support.

The article emphasizes the importance of understanding the potential financial impact of dating before the divorce is final.

Case Study 3: Emotional Challenges and Property Division

In this case study, the article focuses on the emotional impact of dating during divorce. It discusses how the other spouse, who is not dating, may react with anger, hurt, or confrontational behavior.

These emotions can make property division and other aspects of the divorce more difficult. The case study highlights the importance of managing emotions during the divorce process.

Case Study 4: Dating and Child Custody

This case study examines the effects of dating during divorce on child custody determinations. It explains that seeing parents date new partners can be challenging for children, especially older ones, potentially leading them to prefer residing with the other spouse.

The article also mentions the resistance to shared custody agreements and how the judge’s decision may be influenced by the children’s discomfort with the dating parent’s new partner.

Case Study 5: Legal Consequences – Alienation of Affection and Criminal Conversation

In this case study, the article explores the potential legal consequences of dating while separated. It highlights archaic criminal statutes that still consider adultery a misdemeanor in some states.

This introduces the concepts of “alienation of affection” and “criminal conversation” lawsuits, explaining how the wronged spouse can sue a third party or the dating spouse for breaking up the marriage.